When someone says, “You’re too good for me,” it’s often a playful or modest way to compliment you. But why not have a little fun with it? Here are 30 flirty and witty responses that will not only keep the conversation lively but also let your charm shine through. Use these replies to keep things light-hearted and engaging while showing off your sense of humor.
Why Flirty and Witty Responses Matter
Responding with flirty and witty comebacks can turn a simple compliment into a playful exchange. It helps build rapport, shows confidence, and keeps the conversation interesting. Plus, it’s a great way to express your own charm and charisma while making the other person smile.
1. “Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match.”
Story: Someone downplays themselves by saying, “You’re too good for me.” You reply with, “Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match,” to turn it into a compliment.
When to use: When you want to keep the tone positive and affirm their worth.
When not to use: If they seem genuinely insecure or uncomfortable.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match.”
2. “Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches,” to playfully suggest that you’re a great judge of character.
When to use: When you want to be playful and confident.
When not to use: If they are feeling down or need reassurance.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches.”
3. “I guess that makes me your upgrade.”
Story: They modestly claim you’re too good for them, and you reply, “I guess that makes me your upgrade,” to playfully suggest they’ve hit the jackpot.
When to use: When you’re aiming for a humorous and flirty exchange.
When not to use: If they seem to take themselves very seriously.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I guess that makes me your upgrade.”
4. “I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself,” to highlight your authenticity.
When to use: To emphasize your genuine nature and dismiss any notion of superiority.
When not to use: If the person is genuinely feeling inferior.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself.”
5. “Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself,” to balance the compliment and show appreciation.
When to use: To offer genuine praise while deflecting any negative self-perception.
When not to use: If they’re looking for a more playful response.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself.”
6. “If that’s true, then I must be lucky.”
Story: They claim you’re too good for them, and you reply, “If that’s true, then I must be lucky,” to suggest that you’re fortunate to be with them.
When to use: To make the compliment feel mutual and playful.
When not to use: If they’re feeling unsure about themselves.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “If that’s true, then I must be lucky.”
7. “Let’s just say we balance each other out.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you reply, “Let’s just say we balance each other out,” to highlight the complementary nature of your relationship.
When to use: When you want to emphasize mutual benefit.
When not to use: If they’re feeling down and need more reassurance.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Let’s just say we balance each other out.”
8. “Well, I think you’re just right for me.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “Well, I think you’re just right for me,” to show that you see them as a great fit.
When to use: To counter their self-deprecation with a genuine compliment.
When not to use: If they seem to be genuinely down on themselves.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Well, I think you’re just right for me.”
9. “I must be your personal hero then.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you reply, “I must be your personal hero then,” to add a playful, heroic twist to the compliment.
When to use: For a humorous and flirty tone.
When not to use: If they don’t appreciate humor in serious contexts.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I must be your personal hero then.”
10. “Good thing I’m not looking for perfection.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “Good thing I’m not looking for perfection,” to imply that you appreciate them as they are.
When to use: To dismiss the idea of perfection and emphasize acceptance.
When not to use: If they seem to be genuinely feeling inferior.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Good thing I’m not looking for perfection.”
11. “You must have a pretty good taste then.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you reply, “You must have a pretty good taste then,” to compliment their choice.
When to use: When you want to add a flirty twist to their compliment.
When not to use: If they seem to have a serious or low self-esteem issue.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “You must have a pretty good taste then.”
12. “Well, I’m glad I’m your type.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “Well, I’m glad I’m your type,” to reinforce that you’re pleased with their interest.
When to use: To affirm your interest in a playful way.
When not to use: If they’re feeling genuinely insecure.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Well, I’m glad I’m your type.”
13. “If that’s true, then I’m doing something right.”
Story: They claim you’re too good for them, and you reply, “If that’s true, then I’m doing something right,” to suggest that you’re pleased with the situation.
When to use: To acknowledge their compliment while expressing your satisfaction.
When not to use: If they need reassurance or support.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “If that’s true, then I’m doing something right.”
14. “I’m just glad I get to be with you.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I’m just glad I get to be with you,” to shift the focus to your happiness.
When to use: To express genuine affection and appreciation.
When not to use: If they seem to need a more light-hearted response.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I’m just glad I get to be with you.”
15. “I think we’re both lucky in this situation.”
Story: They believe you’re too good for them, and you reply, “I think we’re both lucky in this situation,” to suggest mutual benefit.
When to use: When you want to highlight the positive aspects of your relationship.
When not to use: If they’re feeling particularly insecure.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I think we’re both lucky in this situation.”
16. “You’re not too shabby yourself.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “You’re not too shabby yourself,” to counter their self-deprecation with a compliment.
When to use: When you want to be playful and flirty.
When not to use: If they are feeling particularly down.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “You’re not too shabby yourself.”
17. “I think we’re both just right.”
Story: They believe you’re too good for them, and you reply, “I think we’re both just right,” to suggest that both of you are a great fit.
When to use: To emphasize that you see value in both of you.
When not to use: If they are feeling particularly insecure.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I think we’re both just right.”
18. “Well, I like what I see.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you respond, “Well, I like what I see,” to affirm your attraction and interest.
When to use: To be straightforward and flattering.
When not to use: If they need more reassurance.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Well, I like what I see.”
19. “Good thing I don’t believe in limits.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you reply, “Good thing I don’t believe in limits,” to suggest that you see no boundaries in your connection.
When to use: To emphasize that you don’t see any limitations in the relationship.
When not to use: If they are feeling particularly insecure.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Good thing I don’t believe in limits.”
20. “I’m just happy to be here with you.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I’m just happy to be here with you,” to show that you value their company.
When to use: To express contentment and appreciation.
When not to use: If they need a more playful response.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I’m just happy to be here with you.”
21. “Well, I guess we’re both lucky then.”
Story: They believe you’re too good for them, and you reply, “Well, I guess we’re both lucky then,” to suggest mutual benefit.
When to use: To highlight the positive aspects of being together.
When not to use: If they are feeling insecure.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Well, I guess we’re both lucky then.”
22. “I think you’re pretty amazing too.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I think you’re pretty amazing too,” to return the compliment.
When to use: To balance the compliment and show mutual admiration.
When not to use: If they need more reassurance.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I think you’re pretty amazing too.”
23. “You’re just right in my book.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you reply, “You’re just right in my book,” to suggest that you value them as they are.
When to use: To express that you see them as perfect for you.
When not to use: If they are feeling particularly down.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “You’re just right in my book.”
24. “I wouldn’t want it any other way.”
Story: They claim you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I wouldn’t want it any other way,” to emphasize your satisfaction with the relationship.
When to use: To express contentment and affirm your feelings.
When not to use: If they need more playful encouragement.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I wouldn’t want it any other way.”
25. “Well, you’re exactly what I’m looking for.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you reply, “Well, you’re exactly what I’m looking for,” to emphasize that they meet your standards perfectly.
When to use: To highlight that you see them as an ideal match.
When not to use: If they’re feeling insecure or need reassurance.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Well, you’re exactly what I’m looking for.”
26. “I think we make a great team.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I think we make a great team,” to suggest that you complement each other well.
When to use: To affirm the strength of your partnership.
When not to use: If they’re looking for a more romantic or flirty response.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I think we make a great team.”
27. “I guess that’s why I’m here.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you reply, “I guess that’s why I’m here,” to suggest that you’re interested in them for a reason.
When to use: To highlight your intentional interest.
When not to use: If they need more reassurance.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I guess that’s why I’m here.”
28. “I like to think we balance each other out.”
Story: They think you’re too good for them, and you respond, “I like to think we balance each other out,” to imply that your qualities complement each other.
When to use: To emphasize the complementary nature of your relationship.
When not to use: If they’re feeling insecure.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “I like to think we balance each other out.”
29. “You’re making me blush!”
Story: They claim you’re too good for them, and you respond, “You’re making me blush!” to add a flirty touch and show that you’re flattered.
When to use: To inject humor and flattery into the conversation.
When not to use: If they need a more serious or supportive reply.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “You’re making me blush!”
30. “Maybe, but I think we’re both pretty great.”
Story: They say you’re too good for them, and you reply, “Maybe, but I think we’re both pretty great,” to keep the conversation positive and mutual.
When to use: To balance the compliment and express mutual appreciation.
When not to use: If they need more reassurance or support.
Example:
- Person: “You’re too good for me.”
- You: “Maybe, but I think we’re both pretty great.”
Top 10 Editor’s Choice Replies
- “Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match.”
Situation: To suggest that you’re a great fit together. - “Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches.”
Situation: For a playful and confident reply. - “I guess that makes me your upgrade.”
Situation: To add a humorous twist. - “I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself.”
Situation: To emphasize authenticity. - “Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself.”
Situation: To balance the compliment with genuine praise. - “If that’s true, then I must be lucky.”
Situation: To express gratitude for the relationship. - “Let’s just say we balance each other out.”
Situation: To highlight the complementary nature of your relationship. - “I think you’re just right for me.”
Situation: To affirm that you value them. - “I must be your personal hero then.”
Situation: For a playful, heroic twist. - “Good thing I’m not looking for perfection.”
Situation: To emphasize acceptance and genuine connection.
